That's a good term, "food evangelism". It bothers me too, which is why I try
to post "counterpoints". Fast-5 is NOT about "one diet". I mean, it's
a very good thing to post "what works" and "what doesn't work" ...
that is how we learn. Or "in this study, they found that ... ". Fast-5
is largely about experimentation.
But it's a different thing to say "You have to do this!". It does kind of
ruin the ambiance (and maybe the willingness for people to share
their own experiences).
Perhaps we can put it to Dr. Herring: if the consensus is that
"food evangelism" is off-topic, people who indulge in it can be
put on moderation? I tend to agree with Flippetskater, the people tend
to follow people around, so ground rules are maybe more effective than
unsubbing.
Personally too, I dislike Sparkpeople because of all
the ads, and their emphasis on certain kinds of foods (mostly food
products, not what I would call "real food". I really don't care which
is better, McDonald's or Wendy's!). Being bombarded with the concept of
counting calories leads me away from my primary goal, which is to figure
out "what really works" for my particular body, largely based on what
my own appestat is telling me.
On Fri, Apr 1, 2011 at 7:20 AM, <msdanacat@yahoo.com> wrote:
This group used to be much more friendly, helpful and inclusive. Heather and others were and still are very interesting and educational, and I've learned a lot from them.
For some time though there has been a bullying atmosphere brought on by several members who are, as has been said, overly "food evangelical." The attitudes on display are obnoxious, rude and off-putting, regardless of the merits of the eating program they promote.
I can't blame those who wish to leave, but I will miss reading their contributions. I don't intend to unsubscribe myself, but think I will also check out this newer group.
- Dana
__._,_.___
0 comments:
Post a Comment